MArcomage

It is OP.

Solutions:

1. Add "If not new" so that the opponent has a chance to respond to it. Right now if this card comes quite early in the game, or at a time that the other player has 1-2 uncommon/rare cards in his hand, there is NO way to respond, not even banish.

2. Remove durable, reduce it's cost and prod x0 and add another keyword like Legend or Swift.

You can draw discard or banish by discarded card, but I agree about not new.

We should make it that way for sure.

Damalycus wrote:
You can draw discard or banish by discarded card, but I agree about not new.

Not true. It replaces card with Hidden treasure.

Ah, I completely forgot about that. Then for sure we need that condition.

Although you can still draw common discarder like wish or tribute or militia or...

Damalycus wrote:
Ah, I completely forgot about that. Then for sure we need that condition.

Although you can still draw common discarder like wish or tribute or militia or...

And you need to draw 2 uncommon banishers/discarders at once.

In fact, make this card and Beastmaster to discard a random card from opponent's hand.
I guess Steelbeard would need some kind of buff in that case.

"If not New" has now been added to the card.

Could the Production x0 effect please be moved outside of the If condition such that it would always occur? Otherwise, this card can be played successively while New to trigger the Brigand keyword while gaining regular production as well. I'm not sure how effectively, but ignoring that, it seems that only the positive effect should be limited to when not New and that the negative effect should occur regardless.

This is intentional, we'll see how it plays out.

Nerf hammer bangs hard. Card now UP.

As DPsycho pointed out you can play it even when it has the new card flag to get brigand tokens while avoiding the production x0.

Still the most annoying card in game.
A card that only DESTROYS a game.

suggestion:

If # of Hidden treasures in opponent's hand < 4
Replace highest rarity card in opponent's hand with Hidden treasure

Fithz has the right idea.

Alternatively:

If # of Hidden treasures in opponent's hand < # Brigands in hand
Replace highest rarity card in opponent's hand with Hidden treasure

Or:
Replace highest rarity card in opponent's hand with Hidden treasure
Stock -1 for each Hidden treasure in opponent's hand
(no effect if not enough stock, maybe)

I like this card, mostly because I tend to use it more than have it used against me, but I'll admit it might be a bit powerful.

I wouldn't say it's very powerful. Just hellishly annoying.
I'd propose a completely different approach:

Quick, Brigand
replaces highest rarity card in opponent's hand
with hidden treasure. Summons non-common from your deck.

Make it discrad rare only cards