Yes, but again, most likely you'll use it first and probably discard a rare card. if you don't have any rares, then you don't really mind how he uses it. It can lead to an infinite amount of rounds of discarding, which will probably result to nothing. Again giving him this card is like giving him a worthless gift.the card will keep reappearing in both your hands, and most likely you will be the big winner, as you won't allow him to play anything useful and probably your whole strategy will be based on this card. I like the concept, but it needs some twitching in my oppinion to make it fair enough to be used as an uncommon. Otherwise turn it into a rare.